The Id4 Is Not Yet Available In The Us With Awd So This Test Pits The Rwd Id4 Pro S Against The Awd Model Y Long Range
For many years, Tesla has had the EV market all for itself more or less, but those days are gone now.
All Tesla models currently have rivals coming from legacy automakers, and one of the most promising appears to be the VW ID.4. In AWD guise, its direct competitor from the Tesla range is the Model Y, so a comparison between these two models makes a lot of sense for many buyers.
Thats exactly what the folks from Now You Know YouTube channel did, pitting the range-topping VW ID.4 Pro S against the Tesla Model Y Long Range. Unfortunately, they couldnt get a hold of an AWD ID.4 as US deliveries of the dual-motor variant start in Q4 2021.
That said, the Model Y is superior when it comes to most specs, offering a range of 326 miles versus the ID.4s 250 miles, better efficiency, quicker 0-60 acceleration, two more seats, more cargo space , and the list continues.
While their real-world testing confirmed theres a big gap between the Model Y and the ID.4, one should not forget the former test car is AWD and the latter is RWD. On a side note, we would have preferred a back-to-back comparison, but it appears that the reviewers didnt have both cars simultaneously for reviewat least that’s what the video editing seems to suggest.
Now, theres no contest when it comes to charging either as the Model Y supports 250 kW fast charging while the ID.4 can only take 125 kW. The Tesla also has more tech and gimmicks, superior user experience, and is roomier.
More Tesla Model Y videos
How Long Is The Wait For The Tesla Model Y
You can expect new orders for the Tesla Model Y Performance to be about seven to nine weeks, which will put its delivery sometime in October. However, the Long Range models are a different story. They will not deliver them until November, which could be a deal-breaker if you need a car sooner.
You can always look at the Volkswagen ID.4 as they will be delivered between October and December for All-Wheel Drive versions, while the Rear-Wheel Drive options will be here even sooner.
1260 miles . EPA estimates. Your mileage will vary and depends on several factors, including your driving habits and vehicle condition.
2250 miles . EPA estimates. Your mileage will vary and depends on several factors, including your driving habits and vehicle condition.
3All prices specified are recommended retail prices. Prices are current at the time of publication and subject to change without notice. The Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price excludes destination freight charge, tax, title, license, dealer fees, and optional equipment.
4All prices shown are the U.S. Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price and do not include extra costs, such as, but not limited to, taxes, dealer charges, registration, and transportation. For specific product availability and program information, please visit your local authorized Volkswagen dealer.
5249 miles . EPA estimates. Your mileage will vary and depends on several factors, including your driving habits and vehicle condition.
Processing: Is The Id4 Better Than The Model Y
They also see themselves as having an advantage at VW when it comes to ‘high quality interior’. In fact, Internet forums full of descriptions of serious manufacturing defects on brand new Model Y . Even US customers are already hoping for better copies made in Germany. It is questionable whether the plant in Brandenburg can fulfill hopes right from the start. At VW, the manufacturing defects that appeared on the first ID.3 test car seem to be an isolated case. The second one was significantly better, even if the appearance of the material has decreased considerably compared to the winter grain era. But the ID.4 proved itself In this regard, even during the first test drive in pre-production cars higher class than the compact ID.3.
Recommended Reading: Tesla Model X Key Fob
Exterior And Interior Styling
The exterior design of each SUV reflects their own brand style and image. The Volkswagen ID.4 is unmistakably a VW in its more boxy and solid construction, but its also been given a new, sleeker edge compared to regular Volkswagen SUV models like the VW Tiguan or Atlas. As with many automakers branching into EVs, they want to give their electric models a distinct identity of their own.
The Tesla Model Y also shows its clear connection and relationship to other Tesla models with its signature aerodynamic curves, large and slightly drooping front end, glass roof, and unique body lines. Where the ID.4 looks more like a conventional crossover SUV in its construction, the Model Y feels more like a reinvention.
As you move to the inside, there are some more stark differences. First of all, the Tesla Model Y can seat up to 7 by adding in the optional third row. The ID.4, on the other hand, is built for 5 people maximum. In addition, while both VW and Tesla try to offer an updated interior, VW doesnt go anything like as far as Tesla to do so.
The Model Y cockpit devotes any and all drive information to the massive 15-inch central screen, with no other instrument display. The ID.4 maintains a more regular central touchscreen and instrument cluster style, though the appearance is also updated. Both do offer glass roof designs, which create a great sense of space.
Volkswagen Id4 Vs 2021 Tesla Model Y
With a new addition in the electric vehicles, the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 is giving tough competition to the established 2021 Tesla Model Y. The 2021 VW ID.4 is the future of EVs. You can check out this electrifying SUV here at Quirk Volkswagen, located in Braintree, MA.
The 2021 VW ID.4 is the first EV from Volkswagen that is based on the new Modular Electric Drive Matrix , and it has already won many hearts with its ingenious features.
The only similarity between these two SUVs is that they are EVs. If you are struggling to choose between these two vehicles, we have a comparison for you to make things easier.
2021 VW ID.4 |
Read Also: The New Kia Electric Car
Compare Car Insurance Quotes
About Compare.com
Compare.coms #1 goal is to save you money. We publish resources that are based on hard-hitting data and years of industry experience to help you make more informed decisions with your wallet.
- All of Compare.coms content is written and reviewed for accuracy by a team of experienced writers and editors who are experts on the topics they cover.
- None of Compare.coms content is ever influenced by the companies and brands we partner with.
- Compare.coms editorial team operates independently of any of the companys partnership or business development interests. We publish unbiased information strictly for the benefit of our readers.
- All of the content you see on Compare.com is based on comprehensive analysis and all data is gathered and vetted from trustworthy sources.
The Volkswagen Id4 Has Its Eyes Set On Global Domination
The Volkswagen ID.4 is an electric SUV produced by German automaker Volkswagen. The ID.4 is currently only available in the European market. According to Car and Driver, the electric SUV will be making its way to America for the 2023 model year.
The ID.4 has become extremely popular in Europe. Europe has embraced the transition to electric vehicles more than many other regions of the world. If European sales are any indication of how well the ID.4 could do in the American market, other EVs may have some major competition to look forward to.
The 2022 Volkswagen ID.4 starts at $41,230. It has 245 miles of driving range. Long-range models can achieve as much as 280 miles of driving range. Consumers have found the ID.4 to be both practical and comfortable. Consumer Reports gave the electric SUV an 83/100 for its road test. It got a 5/5 predicted owner satisfaction score. A 100% predicted owner satisfaction score is nothing to scoff at.
The electric SUV also got perfect scores from Consumer Reports for its interior noise level, front-seat comfort, and acceleration. The SUVs biggest point of concern is its predicted reliability rating. Consumer Reports gave the ID.4 a 2/5 for predicted reliability, which isnt great. That being said, a 5/5 predicted owner satisfaction score can offset the vehicles reliability concerns.
You May Like: How Much Is Tesla Suv
How Much Does The Tesla Model Y Cost
There are two versions of the Tesla Model Y available for purchase. The first is the Tesla Model Y Long Range, and it will run you $51,990 starting MSRP,3 while the Tesla Model Y Performance will cost you $60,990 starting MSRP.3 It isn’t the most affordable option, but some other all-electric SUVs are more expensive than these models.
Here’s How The Tesla Model Y Compares With The Volkswagen Id4
Both EVs have plenty to offer, but which one rules supreme?
The electric car war is just getting started. In the beginning, it was only Tesla who seemed to be taking the throne. However, for the past couple of years, many car manufacturers who were in the past at the top of their game with gas cars are now seeming to get a handle on electric cars too.
From names like Ford to Volkswagen, everyone seems to be going green. Tesla has, however, managed to still stay ahead of its competition one way or another. All this can be attributed to them starting the electric journey earlier than their competition.
Tesla vehicles from the Model S to the Model Y have all had one thing in common premium touches that come with an affordable price tag. While Tesla is yet to announce any new addition to their S3XY lineup, they seem to be building on what they already have. Some people would argue that they are improving perfection.
Volkswagen, on the other hand, is joining the electric race with long-term experience in building cars. This is the skills and knowledge that the brand has amassed over the past one hundred years. And with this, they are proving to be worthy contenders for the electric throne. The Volkswagen ID.4 is one of the many cars from the Volkswagen electric lineup that has gained notoriety among VW enthusiasts and those who feel that Tesla is overrated.
Here is how the Tesla Model Y compares with the Volkswagen ID.4.
Read Also: How Much Does The Tesla Car Cost
One Knows And Appreciates One Another
Model Y against ID .4. That sounds like an exciting duel, and not just in terms of the vehicle segment. At the same time, it is also the encounter between two manager alpha animals. Elon Musk versus Herbert Diess. You know and appreciate each other. Musk stopped by VW in Braunschweig as part of his last trip to Germany to get a To do a round with the new ID.3 and take a first look at the ID.4. Diess was already on the road in the Model Y with Development Director Frank Welsch. In the fight for the customers’ favor, however, mutual appreciation will soon be over. Facts count.
Tesla Model Y Vs Volkswagen Id4 Interior
The interiors of the Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 are very different, especially when it comes to the seating fabric. Tesla has custom-engineered a specialty vegan seating that is supposedly great at resisting stains and maximizes comfort.
However, this comes down strictly to your personal preference, as some drivers strongly dislike the feel of this fabric. The VW ID.4, on the other hand, gives you a choice between more traditional options such as cloth or V-Tex leatherette seating and even includes a leather-wrapped steering wheel.
Don’t Miss: New Electric Cars Under 30k
How Do I Buy
Tesla Model Y Tesla Model Y has been available since the year 2020. You can also find some used models for sale.
You can lease a new model if you do not want to finance your Model Y. The 36-month lease for model base Long Range model starts from $766 per month with a minimum of $4,500 due upon signing. The Performance models cost increases to $839 per month, and the exact amount is due upon signing.
Its the VW ID.4 that debuted in 2021 and, while there could be some that are entering the market for used cars, the best option is to purchase a new model through Volkswagen and receive the federal tax credit of $7500. It is possible to lease the ID.4 however, there are no offers for it at the moment youll lease it at the retail price for the model you select. Be aware that leases arent eligible to receive the federal tax credit.
Volkswagen Id4 Awd Pro Vs Tesla Model Y
The VW ID.4 Pro AWD vs. Tesla Model Y electric vehicle comparison is a complicated beast. However, the ID.4 wins out at the end of the day because VW designed an SUV with drivers in mind, not specs. It’s both more comfortable to drive and more comfortable to sit in.
Here at Jim Ellis Volkswagen of Chamblee, we have a wide array of new and used inventory. Our whole team is dedicated to customer service we can hardly wait to see you at our dealership. Contact us today to schedule a test drive.
Read Also: Tesla Stock Price History Before Split
What Are The Interiors Like
All of these EVs present interiors with reimagined functionality and designs that highlight their central touchscreens. Alas, these screens have steep learning curves and annoyances, from general sluggishness to glitches and crashes.
Overall, Tesla’s screen is the snappiest of the trio, but it’s also the only way to view vital information, such as your speed, and control interior functions, including the air vents. The Mach-E and the ID.4 each have a screen behind the steering wheel, which we prefer.
The Tesla’s screen has the most character and variety of applications, from an endlessly entertaining whoopie cushion to Neftlix and even video games. The downside is that many of these features require a monthly subscription. While Tesla gives you up to a year free with the purchase of the vehicle, it’s frustrating to think that the phone you have in your pocket, that you’re already paying for, can do most of these same things. And unlike Ford and VW, Tesla does not support Android Auto or Apple CarPlay smartphone integration.
The Tesla’s lack of physical controls gives the interior a clean, minimalist look at the expense of functionality. In the ID.4 vs. Model Y matchup, the VW looks more traditional but relies on touch-sensitive switches for the majority of its controls. These switches offer no tactile feedback and often require multiple attempts to activate. The result can be maddening during daily use.
2021 Ford Mustang Mach-E.
Tesla Model Y Vs Volkswagen Id4
Starting Market Average
Automatic Emergency Braking
Basic Warranty
Blind Spot System
Surround View Camera
Surround View Camera
Adaptive Cruise Control
Adaptive Cruise Control
Remote Engine Start
Remote Engine Start
Parking Sensors
Parking Sensors
Multi-Zone Climate Control
Multi-Zone Climate Control
Premium Audio
Premium Audio
Also Check: Best Value Electric Car 2022
Reserve Your Volkswagen Id4 Today
Have you decided that the Volkswagen ID.4 is the SUV for you? If so, stop by O’Steen Volkswagen, a Volkswagen dealer in Jacksonville.
We can help you reserve your new VW ID.4 or explore other options within this family of vehicles. Our associates here at our dealership are ready to walk you through the buying process when you decide it’s time to buy your next Volkswagen vehicle.
Let Comparecom Help You Find The Right Electric Crossover
The VW ID.4 and Tesla Model Y are great options in the electric crossover space. Both offer buyers valuable features, efficient electric driving ranges, and stylish looks.
Whichever model you feel is the better option for your next car, Compare.com can help you in your search with our powerful electric car search tool. You can also review our electric car buying guide so you can learn everything you need to know about electric cars before making your decision.
Compare EVs Near You
Nick Versaw
You May Like: Electric Cars Eligible For Tax Credit
Vw Vs Tesla: Suv Utility
If youre in the market for an SUV, then youre searching for an SUV that will offer plenty of capacity for cargo and additional capability in the Des Moines commute.
The Tesla Model Y and the Volkswagen ID.4 offer spacious interiors however, both are smaller. The Tesla Model Y has six fewer cubic feet of cargo space for cargo in its rear trunk than the Volkswagen ID.4, meaning you have more storage space within its trunk than in the VW ID.4 without sacrificing passenger comfort. Check out the trunk space of the VW ID.4 against. Tesla Model Y below:
- VW ID.4 Cargo Space 30.3 cubic feet
- Tesla Model Y Trunk Space: 24.1 cubic feet
In addition to its spacious interior in addition to a spacious interior VW ID.4 also beats the Tesla Model Y with regards to capacity to tow. With a towing capacity of 4,200 pounds and AWD capabilities, youll get an excellent value on this Volkswagen ID.4 at a much less expensive cost as compared to Tesla Model Y. Tesla Model Y.
- Tesla Model Y Towing Capacity 3,500 pounds
- VW ID.4 towing capacity 4200 pounds
Volkswagen Id4 Vs Tesla Model Y: Global Domination
While Tesla is still enjoying overall success, its tough to imagine consumers choosing the Model Y over rivals because of pricing and availability issues. The Model Y is no longer the only game in town.
New electric SUVs are rapidly emerging. As the years go by, competition will only get more fierce. Based on how well the ID.4 is selling in Europe and how far the Tesla Model Y has fallen, the VW ID.4 could overtake the Model Y in the race to create the most popular electric SUV.
Read Also: 2021 Tesla Model Y Review
